Third World Ant

The thoughts of a little ant on a big planet.

Thursday, October 05, 2006

Doctors suck

Most of them, that is. And this is not a statement I can make without pissing off a number of my close friends, who are in their community service year of medicine and ready to be unleashed on the world to do the same thing as the protagonists of this post’s title (be doctors, hopefully not suck, that is).

It is my general aim in life to avoid going to the doctor (and I should be specific here: I mean the GP; my encounters with surgeons are thankfully rare, but in all cases, necessary) like the plague: not because I am afraid of them, not because I don’t fall sick from time to time, but because for the large part, I don’t believe they add any value to my life. The dentist, yes – he does preventative maintenance on my teeth, removes the inevitable plaque build-up, reinforces the enamel with fluoride and whitens them. I make twice-annual appointments, I go to his office, I wait about five minutes to see him, he does his work, I see the pleasing manifestations thereof, I pay him his rather large bill quite willingly. I am a happy dentist customer – in fact, I look forward to my visits.

So why can it not be the same with the GP? Not having been since 1999 (except in the case where I needed a renewed prescription for something) I think I forgot all the reasons why I despised them so much, but I will now relate these to you, so that you can share in my ire (do not attempt to appease me please, I want to be pissed off. Thanks).

What time was my appointment again?

I arrived at 9am (technically 8:55am) yesterday morning for my 9am appointment – that’s what people in the business world do when they make meeting times. If you want me there for 9am, then I’ll be there for 9am. If you don’t want to see me until 9:40am, then kindly inform me before the fact that this will be the case. I was told mine was the first appointment of the day, so why on earth was he seeing another patient before me? (“Was it a sudden emergency?” I asked of the receptionist. “No, just his first appointment,” she replied.) Oh. So you book two people, make one wait while you see the other one, boot them out after a certain amount of time, shuffle the next one in, see them for some amount of time, kick them out, herd the next one in ad infinitum (actually, only until 4:30pm. Heaven forbid you expect your doctor, who is actually a businessman trading in his medical services, to put in the occasional late evening. Only people in the real business world have to do that, you see. Us poor lowly un-MBBCh’d creatures.). What really grates my cheese about this was the nonchalance of the receptionist – she looked at me in a very surprised fashion when I suggested I might have other important things to do that day, and acted like I should have expected to wait for the appointment. She didn’t come anywhere near offering an apology for the delay (neither did the doctor, for that matter). If I’d left, they’d probably still have had the nerve to charge me my consultation fee for failing to cancel the appointment less than 24 hours before it occurred, but I’m pretty sure I’d not be able to convince them to pay me for my lost time – it’s not like I don’t have an income to earn, after all. Or is it that my job is less important than yours?

I’m going to prescribe something for you, whether you need it or not

My doctor friends have confirmed this for me – a GP will bow to your whims and prescribe drugs whether you need them or not, because it feels psychologically better as a patient to know you haven’t forked out your consultation fee for nothing – you’re getting hard-core schedule 5 stuff to zap your ailment, whether or not you need it. Antibiotics for a (virally induced) cold? “In case you develop a bacterial infection now that your immune system is a little down” they’ll whimper. In my mind, drugs are usually designed to treat stuff, not prevent it from infecting you. What you really need to be told is “stop whining, if it’s a sick note you want, I can write a fake one up for you” or “stop dressing like an Oxford Rd hooker at night in the middle of winter – put on a goddamn jersey!” or “take Medlemon and sleep it off, you big baby.”

And we wonder why it is that super drug-resistant bug strains develop (hello XDR!) when we prescribe strong drugs to people who don’t really need them, hence don’t take them properly, hence expose their existing bugs to weaker-than-required levels of the drugs, which in turn develop immunities to them.

[But I must be fair and say that this wasn’t the case with my infection yesterday – of course, in some instances, drugs are truly required (although I did pose to him that it was entirely possible my body would clear itself of the infection on its own, that’s what our immune system is for, after all, isn’t it?)]

I’m going to get all self-righteous on your wayward ass

Now, I expect a GP to tell me all the possible pertinent information about the drugs he’s just so happily prescribed for me. I shouldn’t have to conjure up for him some rather likely scenarios that might be happening in my life to check whether or not the drugs will affect it. Unfortunately, the only way I ever really learn the contraindications of a drug is by reading the package inserts, which are vastly more informative (if somewhat too liberally peppered with medical jargon). See, I’ve learnt that some medication doesn’t go too well with other medication. A while back, when I went on the Pill, the doctor (gynae in that instance) never bothered to tell me that antibiotics reduce its effectiveness. Knowing how frequently doctors prescribe antibiotics, and knowing that people generally fall sick with colds/flu once or twice a year, it is not a highly unlikely event that I’d be taking antibiotics at some point in the future, and accidentally find myself pregnant because the Pill suddenly stopped working. Fortunately, that didn’t happen because I have learnt always to read the damn package insert and look up the words I don’t understand.

Anyhow, back to my appointment yesterday: I waited for him to ask what other medication I might be on, or what other medical problems I might have, in the event that there might be some contraindications for my prescribed drugs (I also asked for anti-malarials, I’m going to Mozam in late October/November). I know for a fact that Larium should not be prescribed to people with certain mental problems, but he wasn’t concerned enough to ask about my mental health. I also know that 10-20% of people on anti-malarials (that’s 1 in 5, not a small percentage at all) suffer side-effects from them, but I had to ask what the side-effects were before he thought to tell me. And the cherry on top, I asked “don’t some antibiotics have any possible effect on any other medication I might be taking?” So he replies: “no, not really, you’re not on the Pill are you?” in a disapproving voice. Now that’s one hell of an assumption to make, and one hell of a judgement to cast. Incompetence is what we call it in the real world.

20 Comments:

At 9:32 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Morning Ant,

I have to go see my GP every 6 months to renew my prescription for the ‘’pill’’. When I wasn’t feeling well the one day, I thought I will be clever and get my prescription at the same time when I went to see him. (Saving me another consultation fee) He prescribed my pill and some antibiotics.

If it wasn’t for my chemist I would probably be a mom today. What really made me cross, is my GP knew I was on the pill!!!! At least now I know, but still we are not suppose to be put under unnecessary risk... And don’t get me starting with the Vet!

I am with you on this one!

 
At 10:05 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Morning Ant

Hope you conquer your infection thingy soon.

Personally I don't believe in antibiotics, I prefer to take natural herbs sprinkled with a bit of common sense :). So far so good, I've managed to clear up a couple of ailments that modern medicine was unable to sort out.

Doctors Schmockters ;)

 
At 10:53 am, Blogger Revolving Credit said...

Next time, go to a sangoma, offer up a chicken and be on your way.

Maybe they'll prescribe smoking some weed in the house to drive the evil spirits aways and a barrel of home brewed beer to cleanse the body.

 
At 11:22 am, Blogger boldly benny said...

DON'T TAKE LARIUM - there's no history of mental health in my family and my sister got violently sick from Larium when she was in Maputo. She had to be flown back to SA on a charter plane by the medical services and the very supportive pilot said, "You're pretty lucky coz I've seen people come into this country and never come out." Mind you you - maybe their doctors didn't tell them about the lethal drug cocktails they were unknowingly taking!

Lucky you to be going to Mozam!

 
At 12:05 pm, Blogger Third World Ant said...

Somali - amen! I wonder if you can sue the doctor for such negligence...

By the way, you should speak to your doctor about having to have a consultation in order for him to write another contraceptive prescription: mine would fax me a new one when I called and said that the old one had run out (at no charge).

Jon - you sangoma you! Can you prescribe some of your remedies for the rest of us? Would they in fact entail Rev's suggested cure-alls?

Rev - you're a master of everything, aren't you? Doctor, philosopher, general pervert...

Benny - thanks for the warning, I've been told about some of the serious side-effects, but I'll be starting to take the drugs before I go to test whether they have such adverse side-effects on me.

I've only ever driven through Mozam before, never stayed, so this is my first official visit! Really excited too, because a very close friend from Vancouver will be out, together with three of his Canadian friends. 8 of us traveling in 2 Landies, it's gonna rock the party...

 
At 1:23 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi Ant,

Thank you for the advise, but every time I go there he takes my blood pressure and so on. (maybe that is unnecessary too? Only they will know) But I will definitely ask him.

Your trip to be sounds great!! Hope you enjoy every second and that you won’t get sick.

Enjoy!

 
At 1:44 pm, Blogger boldly benny said...

Ant your holiday plans sound positively fabulous - I'm trying to organise a trip to Mozambique next year May for my birthday.

Somali I stand to be corrected but I think it varies according to your pill - I know when I was on a stronger pill I had to get my blood pressure checked etc. But I was on the pill to clear up my skin and not as a contraceptive primarily. It might be a good idea to go to a gynae and then you can just give the gynae a call to renew your script every six months.

 
At 10:25 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I had a crazy doctor in Nelspruit who I think got some kind of kick-back from needle and syringe companies or something - everytime
I went to see her I got an injection in my ass, no matter what the problem was. The last straw was going to see her about a spider bite on my leg - wasn't painful at all, but started looking slightly funky. So she gave me a Voltarin shot! Thanks... NOW my leg is sore... What happened to First Do No Harm??!!

 
At 1:44 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

just search the trusty internet for natural remedies as well as reviews for said remedies, that way you can sort through all the chicken related garbage :)

 
At 10:12 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

It's all a conspiracy. These guys overbook more than the airlines. Drives me mad. I only visit the quack when I'm nearly dead (well when I feel that way anyway) and then have to spend another 2 hours waiting in a cough infested waiting room for the doctor to tell me I'm sick because I'm stressed. As if I didn't know that. Just give a note so that I can convince my boss of the same- prescribe me some sort of antibiotic to kill the lung infection and I'll spend the week in bed.

Maybe someone should start a "rate your GP" website with a large weighting toward punctuality.

Larium is quite fun with large quantities of shooters. It will send you on a trip without having to leave the confines of Norwood. Much cheaper than the trip to Moz.

PS Your rugby journo mate sent me a rather sweet email.

Rev: The "barrel of home brew deep cleansing detox diet". You should patent that.

 
At 9:57 am, Blogger Third World Ant said...

Somali - thanks. I'm one of those tough and hardy people who don't generally get sick - if the runs are doing the rounds, I'll be the last to catch them!

Benny - I'm sure I'll be able to show you plenty of pics to convince you that it's worth the effort. Birthday party, eh? That's the best one I've heard of - if only I had the energy to plan mine like that! And now that I think of it, it was my gynae, and not the GP, who faxed me contraception prescriptions.

Mel - you still live in Nelspruit? I know a couple of crazy doctors there doing their community service. Take my advice - stay the hell away from hospitals in Nelspruit!

atw - thankfully I work at a company where if I say I'm sick, I don't need a note to prove it, which saves the even greater sickness-inducing event of having to go to a damn doctor for a note telling me what I already know. The rubgy reporter took her pretty time writing to you, but I'm chuffed she did! If you ever have the good fortune of running into her in person, you'd have an instant new mate - she's a fun-loving, no-nonsense riot.

And Rev should probably copyright most of the twisted things he says, they're all brilliant (I wouldn't personally patent anything he makes though - probably a big danger to society!)

 
At 12:05 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Why do patients wait?

Patients aren't cars that have simple problems that can have routine fix times. People never honor their appointments. People never respect the idea that maybe your problem may not be able to be solved in a flash. So times are not fixed. However, if someone routinely shows up late for their first appt, change doctors. That's just irresponsible.

Why always prescribing?

Americans love to bit#h when don't get immediate results (see last question). So to keep patients who don't want to hear what someone with way more qualifications has to say, prescriptions keep going. Medicine should not be a consumer based industry. People should be fined for heckling doctors. Giving people options on their care is a double-edged sword.

Why self-righteous?

In response, did you train and get your butt kicked for 80+ hours/week for a few years? Probably not, and when people start being jerks because they read something on WebMD, don't expect a nice response. All physicians should ask if you are taking Meds, but people should also keep the following on them in their wallet/purse:
1.Medical problem - when diagnosed, what treatments
2.Surgeries - when, where
3.Allergies - which drug, what happens
4.Meds - name, dosage, time interval, how long being taken

PEOPLE need to be responsible for their medical records. A GOOD history is 80%+ of getting the diagnosis. When people don't care, don't expect your physician to make up for your shortcomings every time. Don't tell them to just look it up. Americans just tend to not be responsible for their own bodies.

 
At 11:12 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I couldn't agree more. I had a common and minor medical issue that the doctor recommended a surgical procedure. It didn't bother me much but just like when you need your wisdom teeth pulled you just do it cuz the doctor says it will help in the long run.

After surgery I ended up with some serious issues from a very routine surgery for a problem that I found it does not require surgery at all. Now I have a chronic illness caused by the surgery that has no cure.

It took me a long time to get over it emotionally but I now know from several articles that doctor's are the third leading cause of death in the U.S. And this does not even account for the people like myself that are walking wounded as a result of doctor's overzealous knives and prescriptions.

The reality of it is that trusting your doctor when prescribing medicine and especially surgery is something that needs heavy research by everyone. Surgery can and even drugs can alter your body and chemistry permanently and leave you in great pain or death. Many doctor's give you the 'quick fix' which often is enough but often do not look at the long term effects and consequences of their treatments. After all most patients will not be with this doctor in a few years.

I cannot change what the doctor's have done to me, but I'd like to spread awareness that some doctor's will do unnecessary surgery to make a buck. Be careful.

 
At 7:50 am, Blogger Matt "The Bull" said...

Love your post, I am an American. Can I assume you all are not?

anyway, our Doctors Suck too, I am an anesthetists and see quack docs all the time. Agree with your summation I do. In America docotors are the only profession that is commercialy protected by the federal government which make them even more corrupt.

 
At 7:34 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

You're full of shit buddy. Do you have any idea what your GPs through to be able to practice medicine in the US? Step 1: get into medical school. This requires getting a 3.5+ gpa in science classes when all of your buddies are acing art history and underwater basket-weaving. Also, you have to score in the top percentage bracket in the country on the MCAT, which basically tests you on all the science you learned in college. Do research, volunteer at hospital, and be president of various clubs in your spare time. Step 2: pay 40 k + per year for medical school, and get through anatomy, histology, biochemistry, epidemiology, biochemistry, physiology, neuroscience, behavioral science, pathology, microbiology, and pharmacology with a passing grade. I bet you don't even know what half of these "ologies" mean. Step 3: pass the first board exam, which is 350 questions long and lasts 8 hours in order to earn the privilege to work in the hospital. step 4: work a shit load of hours in the hospital (during which time you get paid nothing and actually PAY tuition in order to work). Step 5: after successfully passing another 8 hour exam and a 1 hour standardized patient exam, get your MD degree. Step 6: work 80+ hours per week for an average of 45,000 dollars per year (this is called residency -> it lasts 3 years). Step 7: pass a 2 day exam in order to be board-certified in the US.

You may think that your doctor does nothing for you, but chances are you'd f*** up your meds if you were allowed to prescribe for yourself. Sorry, reading wikipedia articles on drugs doesn't give you all the knowledge that a GP accumulates in 7 years of hardcore training. Get a clue dumbass - there's a reason the FDA doesn't allow people to prescribe for themselves.

Someday when you're older (when you actually have real medical problems), maybe you'll appreciate the fact that you can go to a GP doc.

 
At 6:41 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Ok...if someone can help me with this one, I'd be grateful.
I saw my internist for massive pain in the groin and left part of my stomach. He said I had a hernia.
Two weeks later when I finally got my appt. to a surgeon the pain had subsided. I went to this crazy Chinese surgeon who really freaked me out with his off the charts bed side manners. Very aggressive, cuts you off everytime I opened my mouth. Tells me I have no hernia.
He never looked at my Ct scan films or reports on my abdomen.
He took me in the office and said "ok let's Do surgery". HUH?
I thought I had no hernia,....he said well let's go explore. HUH?
NO Thanks....I asked him how many he has done, he said "it's my bread and butter". double huh?
Lastly I said, no thanks for now,
I'm meeting other surgeons and if after a few opinions I feel you are the one to perform the surgery I will call you"/
Today in the mail I received a confirmation on MY SURGERY DATE!
HOSPITAL, WHAT I CAN AND CAN'T EAT, HOW LONG I'LL BE IN THE HOSPITAL!.....ETC.
Are you kidding me? I called livid
and cancelled this bogus surgery.
OH yeh.....most important...he said it's for gallstones. HUHUHUHUH? the Gallbladdr is on the right...isn't it. my pain was on the left. He made no mention I had a problem with the gallbladder
and he didn't even do a abdomen exam.

 
At 6:33 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I am sick and tired of medical narcissists ranting about their education costs and woos. (No one forced you to choose the field, so BEAT IT! You probably wanted the money and prestige in the first place and not healing people!)

These GP narcissists have not a single clue of what other professionals go through to earn their degrees; some of them are even more rigorous and cost even more. Put a string of partial differential equations in front of them, they will probably cry like babies. I work with PhDs day in and day out, no one cared to be referred to as Dr. Compare GPs to theoretical physicists is like comparing the brains of an under-developed chimp to that of Albert Einstein.

Medical narcissists tend to compare themselves to scientists, but the truth of the matter is that they just memorize stuff from a reference book. GPs don't invent anything new, they just regurgitate from memory. Memory does not equal to understanding! GPs are people who can't make it (or good enough) to be a specialists so they have breath but no depth. I hope that some day, their little breath will be replaced by WebMD so that their higher wage may be garnished and given to the poor. If you don't believe it, my pediatrician saw my daughter for 5 minutes, she charged our insurance company $70 for 15 minutes. When confronted about the fraudulent charge, the reply is: why do you care? your insurance pays! I don't care what kind of training you did in school, 5 minutes of your time is not worth $70; you lying and cheating s** of a b****. We had to pay for our insurance you d**b f*** which in turn pays you.

I stress, education may demonstrate potential but it is what you do with your education that counts. If you as a GP over book patients on purpose, charge insurance companies 3 times the time you actually spend with the patient, prescribe drugs at will, then you are a disgrace to the practice. Your acts cost higher insurance premiums for everyone.

I say, it is time that we stand up to these narcissists and stop putting them on a pedestal. They need to learn to treat patients as professionals and customers like any other business. This means, show up on time as scheduled; smile; and say thank you when we write you a check!

 
At 6:44 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I wish they lift the medical quota and allow more doctors to graduate so that they compete for your business. Right now they have way too much bargaining power in congress. I agree whole heartily with the previous speaker!

 
At 6:00 am, Blogger Fat Bastardo said...

Click Here And See Why Americans Kill More People Than the Nazis
Shocking Medical Error Data
Doctor Salaries Click Here

The medical industry is the only industry that makes more money by being incompetent.

Click Here And See Why American Doctors Kill More People Than the Nazis

Shocking Medical Error Data Click Here

Doctor Salaries Click Here

Doctors are greedy and dangerous!

 
At 6:00 am, Blogger Fat Bastardo said...

Click Here And See Why Americans Kill More People Than the Nazis
Shocking Medical Error Data
Doctor Salaries Click Here

The medical industry is the only industry that makes more money by being incompetent.

Click Here And See Why American Doctors Kill More People Than the Nazis

Shocking Medical Error Data Click Here

Doctor Salaries Click Here

Doctors are greedy and dangerous!

 

Post a Comment

<< Home

South Africa's Top Sites